The Centrifuge

A centrifuge has 12 locations for test tubes, located evenly in a circle (let them be referenced as the hour locations on a clock.) Prior to spinning the tubes, the centrifuge must be evenly balanced about its center. Assuming all test tubes weigh the same amount, what numbers of test tubes (from 1 to 12) can be spun without needing to add dummy tubes to balance out the weight? For example, you can't spin 1 tube alone, but can you spin 5 tubes?

Source: rec.puzzles. Used as Ken's Puzzle of the Day 6/6/94.


Solutions were received from Larry Baum, Robert T. McQuaid, Carlos Rivera.

Except for 1 and 11, any number of tubes from 1 to 12 can be balanced. Any even number of tubes can be spun simply by placing pairs of tubes in opposite locations on the centrifuge.

For 3 tubes, place the tubes in the 12, 4, and 8 positions (evenly spaced.) For 9 tubes leave those positions empty instead.

For 5 tubes, add two tubes at opposite locations to the solution for 3 tubes (at the 3 and 9 positions.) For 7 tubes, leave all of these locations empty instead.


Mail to Ken