__ __ __ |__|__|__| |__|__|__| |__|__|__| |
What is the fewest number of matches which must be removed to break all
squares - of any size - in:
|
Source: Based on "Vanishing Trick" in Michael Holt's Math Puzzles & Games, Volume 2, Page 44.
+---+ | | + 1 + match 1 removed +---+ 2 + | | | + 1 +---+ | | | +---+ 3 + match 2 and 3 removed +---+ 2 +---+ | | | | + 1 +---+ 4 + | | | | +---+ 3 + 5 + | | | | + 6 +---+---+ match 4 5 and 6 removed +---+ 2 +---+---+ | | | | | + 1 +---+ 4 + 7 + | | | | | +---+ 3 + 5 +---+ | | | | | + 6 +---+---+ 8 + | | 9 | | +---+---+---+---+ match 7 8 and 9 removed +---+ 2 +---+---+-10+ | | | | | | + 1 +---+ 4 + 7 +---+ | | | | | | +---+ 3 + 5 +---+-11+ | | | | | | + 6 +---+---+ 8 +---+ | | 9 | | | +---+---+---+---+-12+ | 14 | 13 | | =---+---+---+---+---+ match 10-14 removed I'll leave my contribution at showing how easy it is to get to a solution for an 8by8, using copies of the 4by4 layout after the initial removal of the minimum of 9 matches. Explanations: 1- I used stars to make it easier to "see" the four 4by4's 2- the digits in the diagram represent removed matches Notice that all that needs to be done is (going clockwise) placing the 3 additional layouts after a quarter turn: ***** 2 ************************* * | | 4 * | | 1 * * 1 +---+---+---* 9 + 6 +---+---* * | 3 | * | | | 2 *---+---+---+ 7 *---+ 5 + 3 +---* * 6 5 | * | | | * *---+---+---+---* 8 +---+---+ 4 * * 9 | 8 * | 7 | * ********************************* * | 7 | * 8 | 9 * * 4 +---+---+ 8 *---+---+---+---* * | | | * | 5 6 * *---+ 3 + 5 +---* 7 +---+---+---* 2 | | | * | 3 | * *---+---+ 6 + 9 *---+---+---+ 1 * * 1 | | * 4 | | * ************************* 2 *****[KD: Denis wanted me to point out that this 8x8 may not necessarily be a minimal solution with 36 matches removed, but for now it's the best I have.]